-
Website
http://drumsnwhistles.com -
Original page
http://www.drumsnwhistles.com/2005/12/12/politics-of-execution/ -
Subscribe
All Comments -
Community
-
Top Commenters
-
disgustedbyyourblog
29 comments · 1 points
-
tracycoyle
8 comments · 2 points
-
kmilyun
18 comments · 2 points
-
editormom
19 comments · 2 points
-
Marie Carnes
18 comments · 1 points
-
-
Popular Threads
-
Shake your fists, then get real
1 week ago · 16 comments
-
Decision time: Stupak or public option Both? Neither?
4 days ago · 6 comments
-
Death Panels, Progressive Style
2 days ago · 3 comments
-
The Reverse MyBarackObamaTax
3 days ago · 4 comments
-
The Twelve Days of Health Care Reform
2 days ago · 2 comments
-
Shake your fists, then get real
Spiritually, I agree with you that someone's criminal behavior does not justify killing him. It does turn the rest of us into monsters. Forgiveness is what we all should aspire to, for our own well-being and the collective conscience.
However, on an intellectual and emotional level, I think the creep needed to die. Some of the execution cases seem like gray areas, but this one doesn't. This is not a productive member of society who got out of control and killed the creep who raped his child. This isn't a woman who fought back and killed the husband who beat her. (Those cases I think it's unfair to judge because everyone has a breaking point.) But this was someone who killed people for no comprehensable reason at all - multiple people! Each person killed equals many, many victims who suffered a devastating loss. And with no explanation. This was an act of evil and people like that have no business remaining on this planet.
That is my opinion, with all due respect to how you feel on the issue.
I do understand your point of view. I do. I just don't think any of us, criminal or not, have the right to decide who remains on the planet, no matter how strong our desire to take care of them and no matter how evil their acts.
But I'm glad you came and commented! And with a nickname of Puggyspice I suspect we have more in common than differences. ;-)
Take care,
DnW
A couple of years ago I attended a dinner where the keynote speaker was a journalist who knew Tookie Williams; she got to know him during his incarceration, and was present at time of his execution.. She described her experience and the execution to us during the course of the dinner. I remember taking copious notes, thinking, "this is so bloggable" but it was one of many things squeezed together at time of high activity, so it never got blogged. It's all written down on a stack of yellow index cards, though. Next time I run across it, I'll look through it and see if there's anything there worth sharing with you
significant post I ever wrote on this blog, at least in my hierarchy of
important topics. :)